Hedging vs. Stop Loss
In the forex market, hedging and stop-loss are both risk management techniques used to minimize potential losses. However, they operate in different ways.
Hedging in forex involves opening two positions on the same currency pair to reduce the risk of losses in one of the positions. For example, a trader may go long on a currency pair and simultaneously open a short position on the same currency pair. This means that if the market moves in one direction, the trader will be profitable in one position and will lose in the other. The net result is a reduction in overall risk exposure.
Stop-loss orders, on the other hand, are used to limit losses on a single trade. A stop-loss order is an instruction to sell a currency pair if it falls to a certain price level. For example, if a trader buys a currency pair at 1.2000 and sets a stop-loss order at 1.1950, the position will be automatically closed if the price falls to 1.1950. This ensures that the trader’s losses are limited to a predetermined amount.
Stop Loss Techniques
Hedging As Stop-Loss
Hedging is when your trade is on a drawdown, and you take an opposite position to neutralize the exposure to one side.
For example, if you take one lot of EURUSD on a buy, you then hedge it for one lot of EURUSD sell. Obviously, you’ll be flat in the market. However, there are a few negative side effects. This is mainly due to spread changes and swap rate changes.
The value of your hedge will change slightly, but it’s a good way of not letting your trade go into a deep drawdown because you lock your stop loss and give it away to recover. So hedging is very useful for limiting the risk and not having to leave the market.
While it sounds simple, it’s actually a confusing process that involves a lot of practice. It takes a ton of focus on the market confirmation because once you enter a hedging situation, it can be tough to decide what side of the trade to cut and return to a bias on the market.
Once you close one side, you’ll start earning or losing according to the opposite side. So you need to solidify your analysis and understanding of price so you know how to get out of the hedge. If you don’t have the right tools to decide, then hedging is probably not the best option.
Something else to know is how to cut losses. Once you hedge, it’s usually only the negative profitable side. So if you’re hedging because you want to win both sides, it’s not the right mentality because, eventually, you’ll have to cut one side.
In a perfect world, we wouldn’t need to stop loss techniques because we’d all win and keep on winning. However, traders of all skill levels and experience will quickly tell you that such a utopia is not reality.
The non-fantasy market conditions we trade in are full of losses and, at times, devastating ones. Once we accept losses as a mainstay of the forex market, we can then look at reducing these losses. However, instead of eliminating loss (which is impossible), we need to manage loss and limit its potential destruction.
These are the four types of stop-loss techniques available to forex traders:
This is the most commonly used approach when it comes to stopping loss. It’s a simple setup that closes your position automatically when the price hits a certain level.
This is a reassuring method for many traders because it guarantees that if a price goes into an unexpected or prolonged fall, your position will automatically be stopped and contained at a certain level before the bottom of the plunge.
The downside with this is that often a price will go back in your favor after it’s hit the stop loss. On the other hand, a hard stop loss may mean you’ll end up taking a loss for nothing.
It’s important to stress that there’s no right or wrong with this method. It’s just a question of what you’re most comfortable with.
This stop-loss technique will be more familiar to more experienced traders because it takes a lot of practice and works to implement successfully.
Rather than place a stop loss in the market system, traders who deploy mental stops execute the stops manually once a price is where it needs to be.
The benefit of this type of setup is that the trader has absolute control over the stop. If a price is not convincingly moving towards a predetermined stop, the veteran trader can decide not to place the stop until they receive stronger confirmation. This results in floating drawdowns and uncut trades. The trader stays in the game and has the chance to recover back to profitability.
The downside of this type of stop loss is that it requires constant monitoring of the market. Because nothing is left to automation, the trader has to always be on top of their trades.
This technique is also a bit tricky and should only be undertaken by the most experienced and learned traders. Without the proper knowledge, market events can slide a trade into a severe drawdown. This is especially true when the trader doesn’t know how to cut losses.
We Trade Forex – Come trade with us!
don’t use any stop-loss method. Having reviewed their performance, we can tell you firsthand that they often end up very deep, sometimes for days or weeks, in a drawdown before they recover or break even.
This isn’t an ideal method for most people because you’ll end up spending a ton of time in negative, stressful positions. Sometimes it will work out for you, but it only takes one time not to throw you into a crippling position.
Many traders who don’t use a stop loss claim that there will always be a period for recovery because the price fluctuates up and down. These traders anticipate and trade with incredible patience while they’re suffering through a drawdown.
For most traders, this is a self-deceiving practice because they don’t have the mental strength to cut losses. Traders wind up in trouble when they play the market with an all-in mentality.
To work without a stop loss, you need to have a rigid guide for alternative risk management to compensate for the lack of stop loss. This usually involves very low leverage (less than 1 to 1 or even negative leverage). This alternate plan also involves price action condition to cut your trade, another form of mental stop loss.
Only well-trained and disciplined traders should even attempt to do this.
All four types of stop-loss laid out above all have pros and cons. It’s up to you to decide what’s best according to your personality at the end of the day. Some methods require more mental toughness, while some require more patience and practice.
What is clear is that any method you choose, you should stick to and practice. You should be aware of how it affects you emotionally. Work on your trading plan and action plan according to the mental reactions related to losses. Losses are a part of the game, and you’ll need to embrace that.
Don’t use any of these methods to avoid taking losses. You’ll end up misusing the stop loss method since it’s intended to cut losses, not to avoid them